Whinning noise from Engine/Tranny
#16
Originally Posted by travman
So your saying that the BG helped minimize the noise?? Kinda confused since you started the thread with your tranny is making noises and your now saying it works great....
#17
Transfer case I believe.
I had an 03 unfortunately and my car made that noise like 5 different times, everytime it was the transfer case.
They eventually replaced the entire TC and I never heard the noise again, and then I got rid of the car
I had an 03 unfortunately and my car made that noise like 5 different times, everytime it was the transfer case.
They eventually replaced the entire TC and I never heard the noise again, and then I got rid of the car
#19
Evolving Member
iTrader: (6)
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Volo, IL
Posts: 392
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i dont think you guys are talking about trany noise, when the car is idling making noise it shouldn't be the trans (unless it is REALLY messed up) the noise i think you are describing sounds like a vacuum cleaner that sucked up a sock. I think all EVO's do this, it is normal, your probably worrying over nothing.
#20
Evolved Member
iTrader: (26)
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Pittsburgh
Posts: 1,712
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by HiRevnVIII
i dont think you guys are talking about trany noise, when the car is idling making noise it shouldn't be the trans (unless it is REALLY messed up) the noise i think you are describing sounds like a vacuum cleaner that sucked up a sock. I think all EVO's do this, it is normal, your probably worrying over nothing.
#21
Originally Posted by Greg K
if you read his post, you'll notice it says the problem still exists even when stationary. It's not the transfer case in this situation.
#22
Evolving Member
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Maple Shade NJ - All ur base r belong to us
Posts: 473
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by vboy425
the noise come on when i give alittle gas or a lot, even if the car is in neutral. can be the turbo?? the Zeitrnonix datalog show the turbo is holding boost just fine. damn
#23
Originally Posted by JoizeeX
read my earlier post. before everyone scares u (not intentionally) and has u concentrating on tranny/tc/turbo/whatever, just think that it could be something very simple and easy to fix - accessory belt. if the temperatures r going down, the belt shrinks and tightens. i know it sounds like a long shot, but it's one of those things that u wanna eliminate before moving on to serious stuff.
i totally agreed with you. i talk many respected vendor and that's what they told me, and aslo what happend if it's the belt and i don't fix it?
#24
Evolving Member
iTrader: (6)
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: CT
Posts: 163
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I noticed the same noise on my 05 Evo RS....It got a lot worse when temperatures went below 32 F.
It varies with engine RPM, so the blet theory seems true.......
BTW, the EVO is so fun to drive, that I forget about "whinning noise" every time I step on the gas....:-)
I had a lot of cars (96 viper, Mercedes SL55, Mustang GT)....The EVO beats them in almost every category........
Don't forget, You paid 30K for a car that will perform better or same than most 100K cars out there........so quit "whinning" about the "whinning noise"....
It varies with engine RPM, so the blet theory seems true.......
BTW, the EVO is so fun to drive, that I forget about "whinning noise" every time I step on the gas....:-)
I had a lot of cars (96 viper, Mercedes SL55, Mustang GT)....The EVO beats them in almost every category........
Don't forget, You paid 30K for a car that will perform better or same than most 100K cars out there........so quit "whinning" about the "whinning noise"....
#26
Evolved Member
iTrader: (11)
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Boston
Posts: 1,456
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
tonight marks the first night my car has made any sort of tranny noise. Its also at least 25 degrees out too and this is the coldest ive ever driven the car in. The sound is an EXTREME whining and somtimes a 'clunking' depending on engine rpm AND throttle position. Under little acceleration it seems louder and in higher gears it also seems louder.
Could it be a sign of low transmission fluid? I did my own clutch about 2 months ago and im wondering if something went wrong. Im familiar with the typical transmission whine but this is not it.
Could it be a sign of low transmission fluid? I did my own clutch about 2 months ago and im wondering if something went wrong. Im familiar with the typical transmission whine but this is not it.
#27
Evolving Member
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Maple Shade NJ - All ur base r belong to us
Posts: 473
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by vboy425
i totally agreed with you. i talk many respected vendor and that's what they told me, and aslo what happend if it's the belt and i don't fix it?
#28
Evolved Member
iTrader: (14)
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 782
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Mine did the same thing. It was my lower Intercooler pipe. One of my bolt wasnt tighten so the bolt fell out and my pipe was loose. So it made a loud whining noise.
Originally Posted by vboy425
today i knowest my car have a whinning noise coming from the engine bay somewhere. Even at a dead stop i can hear it when i give a little gas and when i let off. the heard the whinning goes up and than drop as the rpm drop. what can it be?? the car drive fine. thanks in advance for any replies
#29
Evolving Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 158
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Reviving this post from the past!
I think you guys are describing the new sound that just arrived in my Evo in the last few hundred miles (currently at ~13,500 miles). I figured I would post up my experience to help those that search later. I throw in a few new key words for kicks .
I too hear a high pitched and not very loud whinning (or squealing or hissing) noise at low rpm. I can hear it between 1k rpm and 2.5 rpm. It sounds slightly metallic - like the noise train wheels make on train tracks at slow speeds - but also slightly airy (hence the word hissing).
I get when the engine is in the 1K to 2.5k range under a number of circumstances. I hear it both when the revs are climbing, dropping or at steady state. I can be stopped with clutch pedal pressed to the floor and the stick in gear and get the noise. I can have my foot off the clutch pedal and have the stick in neutral and get the noise. I can be driving along slowly in gear and get the noise, even without giving gas. For example, if I am doing 30mph in 4th (~2k rpm) the noise will continue even if I take my foot off the gas and coast. If I am a 2k rpm in 4th and go WOT, the noise goes away and I believe it goes away before 2.5k rpm. From what I have experienced, I do not believe that the sound is tranny or awd/transfer-case related.
Also, I don't hear the noise when I first start my car but only after I have driven for a few minutes/miles and the engine is up to temperature.
While some of you say that cold weather exposed the noise for you, it was warm here (60F-90F) when I heard it.
Most of you say this is normal, so I am not going to freak out. I'll see what my mechanic says when I go in for my next service.
Cheers!
I think you guys are describing the new sound that just arrived in my Evo in the last few hundred miles (currently at ~13,500 miles). I figured I would post up my experience to help those that search later. I throw in a few new key words for kicks .
I too hear a high pitched and not very loud whinning (or squealing or hissing) noise at low rpm. I can hear it between 1k rpm and 2.5 rpm. It sounds slightly metallic - like the noise train wheels make on train tracks at slow speeds - but also slightly airy (hence the word hissing).
I get when the engine is in the 1K to 2.5k range under a number of circumstances. I hear it both when the revs are climbing, dropping or at steady state. I can be stopped with clutch pedal pressed to the floor and the stick in gear and get the noise. I can have my foot off the clutch pedal and have the stick in neutral and get the noise. I can be driving along slowly in gear and get the noise, even without giving gas. For example, if I am doing 30mph in 4th (~2k rpm) the noise will continue even if I take my foot off the gas and coast. If I am a 2k rpm in 4th and go WOT, the noise goes away and I believe it goes away before 2.5k rpm. From what I have experienced, I do not believe that the sound is tranny or awd/transfer-case related.
Also, I don't hear the noise when I first start my car but only after I have driven for a few minutes/miles and the engine is up to temperature.
While some of you say that cold weather exposed the noise for you, it was warm here (60F-90F) when I heard it.
Most of you say this is normal, so I am not going to freak out. I'll see what my mechanic says when I go in for my next service.
Cheers!
#30
Evolving Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 158
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Update.
I took my car to Mitsu to get the whine looked at. The tech pinpointed the upper drivebelt pulley (the pulley that is highest up and closest to the nose of the car) as the source of the noise. He also thought that the water pump bearing might have been noisey. They ended up replacing the pulley, water pump and drive belt. In the process the tech saw that belt rubber was building up on the pulley - perhaps if ignored this problem might have resulted in premature belt breakage.
Thankfully, the noise is now completely fixed.
I took my car to Mitsu to get the whine looked at. The tech pinpointed the upper drivebelt pulley (the pulley that is highest up and closest to the nose of the car) as the source of the noise. He also thought that the water pump bearing might have been noisey. They ended up replacing the pulley, water pump and drive belt. In the process the tech saw that belt rubber was building up on the pulley - perhaps if ignored this problem might have resulted in premature belt breakage.
Thankfully, the noise is now completely fixed.
Last edited by 286bhp; Aug 14, 2008 at 07:35 AM.