Exedy Stg1... Who's got one, what do you think?
Dec 28, 2008, 12:56 PM
#16
Former Sponsor
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Chicagoland
Posts: 984
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yes, the Exedy Stg 2 is a puck style clutch. It is a bit more aggressive than the organic but the added holding power and longevity you gain is worth it IMO.
You went a long time on your stock clutch and I am sure the Stg 1 would suit you fine. I would most likely compare it to a stock replacement clutch.
You went a long time on your stock clutch and I am sure the Stg 1 would suit you fine. I would most likely compare it to a stock replacement clutch.
Dec 28, 2008, 01:24 PM
#18
The problem with the Stg1 Exedy is that the pressure plate has more clamping force which causes the disc to wear faster than the OEM combo. Plus it makes the engagement very rough for a full face clutch - I liken it to a puck style clutch as far as roughness. btw.. The OEM clutch is an Exedy unit and it's painted purple like their Stg4 racing clutches. The Exedy Stg1 is not purple like their racing clutches, in fact it could be made in china for all I know. Scott from TTP has said numerous times that the OEM clutch is a better unit than the Stg1 and now I believe him based on my experience with it. Or at least the pressure plate and disc seem to be better matched. That's a big part of the Stg1's problem is that the pedal is very heavy which makes smooth engagement even more difficult than it would be if the pedal didnt require so much force. Literally I put it in neutral at stoplights as my leg gets tired of holding it.
I'll say it again, if you got 60K from the OEM - stick with it. No need to void your powertrain warranty if you still have one. You dont have to have mitsubishi install it, you can order from the mitsu parts guy on here and even get a discount. But if your looking for something stronger to hold more power, look at a different clutch than the Stg1. I have no axe to grind, IMO Exedy makes fine clutches but the stg1 is not a good combo for the Evo. Sucks that I'm having to do my own clutch again after only 12mos.
Other clutches that we've installed / driven.
Exedy Twin SD - Light pedal, mild engagement, noisey twin chatter, expensive, very strong
Fidanza Carbon Kevlar 3.2 - very light pedal, smooth engagement, no chatter, expensive for a single, strong
Exedy stg1 - medium-heavy pedal, rough engagement, light chatter, doesnt like abuse
OEM - light pedal, smooth engagement, no chatter, doesnt like abuse
I'll say it again, if you got 60K from the OEM - stick with it. No need to void your powertrain warranty if you still have one. You dont have to have mitsubishi install it, you can order from the mitsu parts guy on here and even get a discount. But if your looking for something stronger to hold more power, look at a different clutch than the Stg1. I have no axe to grind, IMO Exedy makes fine clutches but the stg1 is not a good combo for the Evo. Sucks that I'm having to do my own clutch again after only 12mos.
Other clutches that we've installed / driven.
Exedy Twin SD - Light pedal, mild engagement, noisey twin chatter, expensive, very strong
Fidanza Carbon Kevlar 3.2 - very light pedal, smooth engagement, no chatter, expensive for a single, strong
Exedy stg1 - medium-heavy pedal, rough engagement, light chatter, doesnt like abuse
OEM - light pedal, smooth engagement, no chatter, doesnt like abuse
Dec 28, 2008, 01:59 PM
#19
The problem with the Stg1 Exedy is that the pressure plate has more clamping force which causes the disc to wear faster than the OEM combo. Plus it makes the engagement very rough for a full face clutch - I liken it to a puck style clutch as far as roughness. btw.. The OEM clutch is an Exedy unit and it's painted purple like their Stg4 racing clutches. The Exedy Stg1 is not purple like their racing clutches, in fact it could be made in china for all I know. Scott from TTP has said numerous times that the OEM clutch is a better unit than the Stg1 and now I believe him based on my experience with it. Or at least the pressure plate and disc seem to be better matched. That's a big part of the Stg1's problem is that the pedal is very heavy which makes smooth engagement even more difficult than it would be if the pedal didnt require so much force. Literally I put it in neutral at stoplights as my leg gets tired of holding it.
I'll say it again, if you got 60K from the OEM - stick with it. No need to void your powertrain warranty if you still have one. You dont have to have mitsubishi install it, you can order from the mitsu parts guy on here and even get a discount. But if your looking for something stronger to hold more power, look at a different clutch than the Stg1. I have no axe to grind, IMO Exedy makes fine clutches but the stg1 is not a good combo for the Evo. Sucks that I'm having to do my own clutch again after only 12mos.
Other clutches that we've installed / driven.
Exedy Twin SD - Light pedal, mild engagement, noisey twin chatter, expensive, very strong
Fidanza Carbon Kevlar 3.2 - very light pedal, smooth engagement, no chatter, expensive for a single, strong
Exedy stg1 - medium-heavy pedal, rough engagement, light chatter, doesnt like abuse
OEM - light pedal, smooth engagement, no chatter, doesnt like abuse
I'll say it again, if you got 60K from the OEM - stick with it. No need to void your powertrain warranty if you still have one. You dont have to have mitsubishi install it, you can order from the mitsu parts guy on here and even get a discount. But if your looking for something stronger to hold more power, look at a different clutch than the Stg1. I have no axe to grind, IMO Exedy makes fine clutches but the stg1 is not a good combo for the Evo. Sucks that I'm having to do my own clutch again after only 12mos.
Other clutches that we've installed / driven.
Exedy Twin SD - Light pedal, mild engagement, noisey twin chatter, expensive, very strong
Fidanza Carbon Kevlar 3.2 - very light pedal, smooth engagement, no chatter, expensive for a single, strong
Exedy stg1 - medium-heavy pedal, rough engagement, light chatter, doesnt like abuse
OEM - light pedal, smooth engagement, no chatter, doesnt like abuse
I was aware the OE is made by Exedy, and I think the stock clutch is a good piece. I just want something that can take a little more abuse than it can. I don't need a puck style though. Such is my dilemma...
Dec 28, 2008, 02:44 PM
#21
Evolving Member
iTrader: (17)
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: New York City
Posts: 326
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i had the exedy stage 1 in my integra and my last evo, it served me well. i currently have the ACT HDSS with no lockout issues. I went with the ACT HDSS since i heard nothing but good things about it but the exedy stage 1 is a decent clutch if you dont have a high hp car.
Dec 29, 2008, 08:52 AM
#22
The OEM clutch is better than the EXEDY stage 1. We've never seen a clutch burn up faster than the stage 1 EXEDY.
We do have a specialty model ACT which has a stocklike pedal effort with the holding capacity of 600tq which we have installed over a hundred of. Many of our top stock turbo customers have used them well into the low 11's. Driveability is still good and there are no lockouts at high rpms experienced with the unit.
Let us know if you are interested and we can provide you more info via PM.
We do have a specialty model ACT which has a stocklike pedal effort with the holding capacity of 600tq which we have installed over a hundred of. Many of our top stock turbo customers have used them well into the low 11's. Driveability is still good and there are no lockouts at high rpms experienced with the unit.
Let us know if you are interested and we can provide you more info via PM.
The problem with the Stg1 Exedy is that the pressure plate has more clamping force which causes the disc to wear faster than the OEM combo. Plus it makes the engagement very rough for a full face clutch - I liken it to a puck style clutch as far as roughness. btw.. The OEM clutch is an Exedy unit and it's painted purple like their Stg4 racing clutches. The Exedy Stg1 is not purple like their racing clutches, in fact it could be made in china for all I know. Scott from TTP has said numerous times that the OEM clutch is a better unit than the Stg1 and now I believe him based on my experience with it. Or at least the pressure plate and disc seem to be better matched. That's a big part of the Stg1's problem is that the pedal is very heavy which makes smooth engagement even more difficult than it would be if the pedal didnt require so much force. Literally I put it in neutral at stoplights as my leg gets tired of holding it.
I'll say it again, if you got 60K from the OEM - stick with it. No need to void your powertrain warranty if you still have one. You dont have to have mitsubishi install it, you can order from the mitsu parts guy on here and even get a discount. But if your looking for something stronger to hold more power, look at a different clutch than the Stg1. I have no axe to grind, IMO Exedy makes fine clutches but the stg1 is not a good combo for the Evo. Sucks that I'm having to do my own clutch again after only 12mos.
Other clutches that we've installed / driven.
Exedy Twin SD - Light pedal, mild engagement, noisey twin chatter, expensive, very strong
Fidanza Carbon Kevlar 3.2 - very light pedal, smooth engagement, no chatter, expensive for a single, strong
Exedy stg1 - medium-heavy pedal, rough engagement, light chatter, doesnt like abuse
OEM - light pedal, smooth engagement, no chatter, doesnt like abuse
I'll say it again, if you got 60K from the OEM - stick with it. No need to void your powertrain warranty if you still have one. You dont have to have mitsubishi install it, you can order from the mitsu parts guy on here and even get a discount. But if your looking for something stronger to hold more power, look at a different clutch than the Stg1. I have no axe to grind, IMO Exedy makes fine clutches but the stg1 is not a good combo for the Evo. Sucks that I'm having to do my own clutch again after only 12mos.
Other clutches that we've installed / driven.
Exedy Twin SD - Light pedal, mild engagement, noisey twin chatter, expensive, very strong
Fidanza Carbon Kevlar 3.2 - very light pedal, smooth engagement, no chatter, expensive for a single, strong
Exedy stg1 - medium-heavy pedal, rough engagement, light chatter, doesnt like abuse
OEM - light pedal, smooth engagement, no chatter, doesnt like abuse
Dec 29, 2008, 11:44 AM
#24
i had an exedy stage 1 in my car for about 15,000 miles and had to replace it. I hated the clutch from day one. I had it w/ a gruppe s flywheel. The pedal is very heavy, engagement sucks, and lots of chatter. I now have a ACT HDSS w/ a new gruppe s flywheel and it is fine. The pedal "feel" is way lighter and it engages very well.
I would highly recommend you choose another clutch other than the exedy stage 1.
I would highly recommend you choose another clutch other than the exedy stage 1.
Last edited by joseph k; Nov 12, 2010 at 02:08 AM.
Dec 29, 2008, 11:46 AM
#25
ACT HDSS it holds more than a Stage 2 Exedy and isn't a puck style disc.
It also cost $500 from vendors on here.
If you daily drive your car stay away from puck style clutches. Puck style clutches are not meant for daily driving they are made for track days.
ACT HDSS holds about 500 WTQ and feels just like stock.
I run the HDSS sprung street disc with a stock resurfaced flywheel, it gets the job done.
P.S. dont waste your time with Exedy unless its a twin disc
It also cost $500 from vendors on here.
If you daily drive your car stay away from puck style clutches. Puck style clutches are not meant for daily driving they are made for track days.
ACT HDSS holds about 500 WTQ and feels just like stock.
I run the HDSS sprung street disc with a stock resurfaced flywheel, it gets the job done.
P.S. dont waste your time with Exedy unless its a twin disc
Last edited by beemerfreak; Dec 29, 2008 at 11:49 AM.
Jul 21, 2010, 01:35 PM
#26
Evolving Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: May 2006
Location: wIndy cIty
Posts: 241
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
sorry for bumping such an old thread........
Just got off the phone with Shep trans and they suggest the Exedy stg1 w/ organic disc for stock to mild evo's. I told him I was making 300-330whp and the Exedy st1 w/ organic disc is what they recommended. Most other clutches are over kill.
I am currently running ACT HDSS kit with resurfaced,stock flywheel and have had no problems with it. But this time I think I'm going to go with the Exedy. Just my .02 cents
Just got off the phone with Shep trans and they suggest the Exedy stg1 w/ organic disc for stock to mild evo's. I told him I was making 300-330whp and the Exedy st1 w/ organic disc is what they recommended. Most other clutches are over kill.
I am currently running ACT HDSS kit with resurfaced,stock flywheel and have had no problems with it. But this time I think I'm going to go with the Exedy. Just my .02 cents
Jul 22, 2010, 10:52 AM
#27
i had an exedy stage 1 in my car for about 15,000 miles and had to replace it. I hated the clutch from day one. I had it w/ a gruppe s flywheel. The pedal is very heavy, engagement sucks, and lots of chatter. I now have a ACT HDSS w/ a new gruppe s flywheel and it is fine. he pedal "feel" is way lighter and it engages very well.
I would highly recommend you choose another clutch other than the exedy stage 1.
I would highly recommend you choose another clutch other than the exedy stage 1.
Last edited by joseph k; Nov 12, 2010 at 02:08 AM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Lucas English
Evo Engine / Turbo / Drivetrain
184
Feb 5, 2017 10:37 PM
Aby@MIL.SPEC
Evo Engine / Turbo / Drivetrain
8
May 18, 2016 05:39 PM
Raptord
Evo Engine / Turbo / Drivetrain
21
Mar 2, 2016 07:42 AM
