New for new, I'd pick the Evo. Some of you might call me crazy, but I see the Evo as a superior car to the M3. Sure the M3 may look pretty good (which is subjective anyway), have alot of creature comforts and attract girls, but I would take the Evo anyday over it. Besides, if you have to use a car to get chicks...then you have other problems you need to attend to.

 

Hey man I just got 06 MR man that car has a lot of power with good driving u'll destroy M3 lol. I'm still stuck and I took stage 1 SRT-4 and those are fast I know my friend owns one

 

i drove my friend's 6spd 2002 m3 about 4 nights ago. did a couple of on-ramp pulls....it's a beast. the s54 loves to be revved!! i can see how above 100mph stock vs stock the m3 will walk an Evo. chirping second gear is pretty awesome too

the car is very very comfortable, almost as good as my mom's rx330. however, it feels a bit heavy in the corners the car is very balanced thanks to 50/50 weight distribution, and the body roll was pretty minimal. the backseats are very roomy. overall the car is pure sex.

however, the m3 is too soft for me at this point in life. the Evo feels just right; the driver feels much more involved with an Evo. maybe later on when i'm older i'll start to appreciate cars with more creature comforts

 

I love my car but i give two votes for the M3!!!!!!!!