View Poll Results: Which one do you like better
DYNO FLASH (PROUVEN)
50
44.64%
XEDE (VISHNU)
62
55.36%
Voters: 112. You may not vote on this poll
DYNOFLASH (Pruven) Vs. XEDE (VISHNU)
#31
iTrader: (24)
Originally posted by Alfriedesq
Finally - on re-sale values of the exed or similar units. If you look on the www.nasioc.com forum you'll find that you can hardly GIVE old vishnu unichips away. the resale is almost nothing. I would think when you spend $30,000 on a car the most important issue is which system is going to work better on the car.
Finally - on re-sale values of the exed or similar units. If you look on the www.nasioc.com forum you'll find that you can hardly GIVE old vishnu unichips away. the resale is almost nothing. I would think when you spend $30,000 on a car the most important issue is which system is going to work better on the car.
I defy and through the mail tuner to match the quaility tune you can get when dyno tuning the car on a dyno and making the tune on a custom basis.
As far as sharing maps - I do not recomend that in any situation. A dyno map is tailored to a specific car. To me it makes no sense to share maps as the EVOs have a very great car to car variance. The idea of tuning is to optimize the tune to match your particular car. Thats how you get the most power in a safe manner and get that razor sharp "tuned" feel when you step on the gas.
If I was in with a shop like you are and had basically unlimited reflashing, I'd probably use it too. But for the majority of Evo drivers, Milford, CT might as well be the North Pole.
#32
Evolved Member
iTrader: (6)
Originally posted by DrMerl
Could this lean towards a sort of library of reflashes that could be shared among a network of cooperating tuners? That way we might get more reflash locations because there'd be a ready supply of nationally tested maps. Maps are free, but the dealer, after buying purchasing his equipment, cannot charge for the map, just his "services". Would that help people to share in this case? I really think ECU reflashes are the way to go for daily drivers. JWT has been doing this (working with the factory ECU) for years with great success.
Could this lean towards a sort of library of reflashes that could be shared among a network of cooperating tuners? That way we might get more reflash locations because there'd be a ready supply of nationally tested maps. Maps are free, but the dealer, after buying purchasing his equipment, cannot charge for the map, just his "services". Would that help people to share in this case? I really think ECU reflashes are the way to go for daily drivers. JWT has been doing this (working with the factory ECU) for years with great success.
Any tuner who tunes through the mail is making a calculated trade off of saftey vs. power and has to add in a large measure of saftey to allow for car to car variance
THERE IS NO WAY to get a lot of power - safely - when you are not doing the tune ON THE CAR
Of course - there is more $$$ to be made selling units through the mail - once you have the map it takes 5 mins to program it in and there is ZERO cost . The way we are doing requires a $100,000 dyno machine, someone to operate the dyno - lots of effort strapping down the car and a whole hour of time to run it. We feel its the ONLY safe way to tune the EVO 8's so that is the way we are doing it.
When you JUST rent the dyno for an hour to tune a SAFC, emanage or other device it costs $250.00 per hour just for the dyno time - - so I think its a real value for $450.00 to have the tune and dyno time included
#34
Evolved Member
iTrader: (6)
Originally posted by Noize
That is the most wafer thin weak argument I've ever seen you waste the time to type. The reason the bottom fell out on Unichips is because they are being replaced with all in one units like the XEDE and UTEC. You'll notice that resale values on both those units are quite high. You're going to have to be A LOT more convincing than that.
I defy you to come back to earth and realize that there are more people near San Fransisco, CA with Evos than in Milford, CT. News flash, anybody in the middle cannot get a custom tune from either shop! At least with the XEDE you can start with a close map and then datalog and fine tune the system yourself. Also notice that in the poll, the Xede is winning by a pretty wide margin. It costs more, but you get end user control over every parameter.
As opposed to the WRX which was a lot more dangerous? Vishnu and TXS customers didn't have any problems there. You start with a base map with an XEDE, and you can use any AWD dyno in the country with a wideband O2 to tune your car. With your reflash, you're screwed with whatever they give you if you don't do it on site, and you have to go back everytime you mod to get it reflashed... again... and again. The XEDE will give you a very close map to start from.
If I was in with a shop like you are and had basically unlimited reflashing, I'd probably use it too. But for the majority of Evo drivers, Milford, CT might as well be the North Pole.
That is the most wafer thin weak argument I've ever seen you waste the time to type. The reason the bottom fell out on Unichips is because they are being replaced with all in one units like the XEDE and UTEC. You'll notice that resale values on both those units are quite high. You're going to have to be A LOT more convincing than that.
I defy you to come back to earth and realize that there are more people near San Fransisco, CA with Evos than in Milford, CT. News flash, anybody in the middle cannot get a custom tune from either shop! At least with the XEDE you can start with a close map and then datalog and fine tune the system yourself. Also notice that in the poll, the Xede is winning by a pretty wide margin. It costs more, but you get end user control over every parameter.
As opposed to the WRX which was a lot more dangerous? Vishnu and TXS customers didn't have any problems there. You start with a base map with an XEDE, and you can use any AWD dyno in the country with a wideband O2 to tune your car. With your reflash, you're screwed with whatever they give you if you don't do it on site, and you have to go back everytime you mod to get it reflashed... again... and again. The XEDE will give you a very close map to start from.
If I was in with a shop like you are and had basically unlimited reflashing, I'd probably use it too. But for the majority of Evo drivers, Milford, CT might as well be the North Pole.
Its true if your not in the NY metro area your prob too far away - but the poplulation within 100 miles of Milford, CT is very very large
We prefer to stick with a car by car system as Pruven's name and reputation is way too important to risk having problems with slow and dangerous tune through the mail set ups
If you started with a base map exede paid for a dyno and someone to adjust your exede and the softwear you need you will be way over $1,000.00. Then you woudl still have a piggy back BTW - I think the exede and the emanage are great products - obvioulsy tailored more to a do it yourself customer who knows how to tune
The Dyno Flash is geared more to someone who wants to get instant great results without guess work and a lot of wasted time tuning the car on the street
I find re-flahses superior to piggy backs - I've been watching what WRX owners are doing with reflashes and they have gotten some great results
#35
Evolved Member
iTrader: (11)
dynoflash all the way
I have seen to many people with sandalone systems f-ck there motor up trying to play tune master on the street all it takes is one hard knock. The dyno is the ****, and $450 is worth it. you do get a print out of how much power you make. It's better than the butt dyno, i have seen people leaving the dyno making 50 and more hp. At $250 per hr for dyno time you are paying $200 for minimum 20hp. what mod can you do to your car for $200 and get a dyno sheet and 20 hp? you buy a standalone or piggy back for $300 up to $1000 and you still need to put that thing on the dyno? what it comes down to is that don't just get one mod and run to get the reflash. when I first had halteck on my dsm i felt big gains in the butt dyno untill i got to the dyno and found out what real power feel like. without the dyno tune i would have never made my firts 11 sec past.
I have seen to many people with sandalone systems f-ck there motor up trying to play tune master on the street all it takes is one hard knock. The dyno is the ****, and $450 is worth it. you do get a print out of how much power you make. It's better than the butt dyno, i have seen people leaving the dyno making 50 and more hp. At $250 per hr for dyno time you are paying $200 for minimum 20hp. what mod can you do to your car for $200 and get a dyno sheet and 20 hp? you buy a standalone or piggy back for $300 up to $1000 and you still need to put that thing on the dyno? what it comes down to is that don't just get one mod and run to get the reflash. when I first had halteck on my dsm i felt big gains in the butt dyno untill i got to the dyno and found out what real power feel like. without the dyno tune i would have never made my firts 11 sec past.
#36
Originally posted by EVOMIZ
dynoflash all the way
I have seen to many people with sandalone systems f-ck there motor up trying to play tune master on the street all it takes is one hard knock.
dynoflash all the way
I have seen to many people with sandalone systems f-ck there motor up trying to play tune master on the street all it takes is one hard knock.
BTW, dynos are only $100-$150 per hour. $250/hour is another crazy number which I'm not willing to pay. What a ripoff...is all i can say..
Last edited by bbyevo8; Sep 17, 2003 at 07:26 PM.
#37
Evolved Member
iTrader: (11)
i think it sill says newbie under your name also
i tell you what i am not new to standalone and i know its not for most people, it's not something you want to test on your brand new car without a dyno.
i tell you what i am not new to standalone and i know its not for most people, it's not something you want to test on your brand new car without a dyno.
Originally posted by bbyevo8
Alfriedesq's car was "dynotuned" and he still f-ck his motor (in your own words). Good luck EVOMIZ, I would very much rather use a "safe" map and sacrifice 10hp instead on going all crazy and having my car in the shop every other week like Alfriedesq's car. Besides have you been on the board for long EVOMIZ?? Alfriedesq was just but a ECU newbie a couple months ago...where shiv corrected him on many of his ECU and tuning misconceptions. I still don't trust him and all his salesman talk.
Alfriedesq's car was "dynotuned" and he still f-ck his motor (in your own words). Good luck EVOMIZ, I would very much rather use a "safe" map and sacrifice 10hp instead on going all crazy and having my car in the shop every other week like Alfriedesq's car. Besides have you been on the board for long EVOMIZ?? Alfriedesq was just but a ECU newbie a couple months ago...where shiv corrected him on many of his ECU and tuning misconceptions. I still don't trust him and all his salesman talk.
#38
Originally posted by EVOMIZ
i think it sill says newbie under your name also
i tell you what i am not new to standalone and i know its not for most people, it's not something you want to test on your brand new car without a dyno.
i think it sill says newbie under your name also
i tell you what i am not new to standalone and i know its not for most people, it's not something you want to test on your brand new car without a dyno.
#39
Evolved Member
iTrader: (6)
Originally posted by bbyevo8
Alfriedesq's car was "dynotuned" and he still f-ck his motor (in your own words). Good luck EVOMIZ, I would very much rather use a "safe" map and sacrifice 10hp instead on going all crazy and having my car in the shop every other week like Alfriedesq's car. Besides have you been on the board for long EVOMIZ?? Alfriedesq was just but a ECU newbie a couple months ago...where shiv corrected him on many of his ECU and tuning misconceptions. I still don't trust him and all his salesman talk.[B}
BTW, dynos are only $100-$150 per hour. $250/hour is another crazy number which I'm not willing to pay. What a ripoff...is all i can say..
Alfriedesq's car was "dynotuned" and he still f-ck his motor (in your own words). Good luck EVOMIZ, I would very much rather use a "safe" map and sacrifice 10hp instead on going all crazy and having my car in the shop every other week like Alfriedesq's car. Besides have you been on the board for long EVOMIZ?? Alfriedesq was just but a ECU newbie a couple months ago...where shiv corrected him on many of his ECU and tuning misconceptions. I still don't trust him and all his salesman talk.[B}
BTW, dynos are only $100-$150 per hour. $250/hour is another crazy number which I'm not willing to pay. What a ripoff...is all i can say..
My built motor suffered a rare, unusual intake valve guide break which had nothing to do with tuning - but rather was prob a fluke casting defect. The bottom line is that if you want to try and make 600 hp on a 2.0 L you are going to have some issues if everything is not perfect and its not going to last for 100,000 miles like a factory motor at 300 hp - - in reality this has NOTHING to do with tuning or the dyno-flash
I am no ecu "newbie" - I've been at this for some time already and I can tell you that Pruven is one of the top few 4g63 tuners in the USA - they certainly are more than competant to re-adjust the factory fuel and ign curves - which are very basic procedures.
You can rent the Pruven dyno for $150.00 per hour just for the dyno - you tune yourself ; $185.00 with a/f sniffer - and its $250.00 and hour when they actually do the tuning on your car. I think these prices are in line with what other shops charge for tuning
#40
Evolving Member
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Las Vegas
Posts: 329
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I don't get it Al just last month you were praising WORKS and how with there through the mail reflash you had achieved so much. Now you state:
"We prefer to stick with a car by car system as Pruven's name and reputation is way too important to risk having problems with slow and dangerous tune through the mail set ups"
Were you happy with the WORKS through the mail flash? If so why would you now be calling it dangerous? Am I missing something? I realize in context you were refering to the Exede but WORKS is through the mail also and you had nothing but good things to say.
"We prefer to stick with a car by car system as Pruven's name and reputation is way too important to risk having problems with slow and dangerous tune through the mail set ups"
Were you happy with the WORKS through the mail flash? If so why would you now be calling it dangerous? Am I missing something? I realize in context you were refering to the Exede but WORKS is through the mail also and you had nothing but good things to say.
Last edited by mojo; Sep 17, 2003 at 09:40 PM.
#41
Evolved Member
iTrader: (6)
Originally posted by mojo
I don't get it Al just last month you were praising WORKS and how with there through the mail reflash you had achieved so much. Now you state:
"We prefer to stick with a car by car system as Pruven's name and reputation is way too important to risk having problems with slow and dangerous tune through the mail set ups"
Were you happy with the WORKS through the mail flash? If so why would you now be calling it dangerous? Am I missing something?
I don't get it Al just last month you were praising WORKS and how with there through the mail reflash you had achieved so much. Now you state:
"We prefer to stick with a car by car system as Pruven's name and reputation is way too important to risk having problems with slow and dangerous tune through the mail set ups"
Were you happy with the WORKS through the mail flash? If so why would you now be calling it dangerous? Am I missing something?
Also - I love the works throttle body and it has proven its worth on the dyno
Just because other tuners are doing through the mail tunes DOES NOT MEAN that every tuner has to do it.
ALL it means is that www.dynoflash.com is NOT comfortable doing through the mail tunes and is NOT interetsed in making $$ that way. Too much is left to chance and too much of the power must be left on the table to maintain a good margin of saftey to allow for car to car variance, altitude differnces, fuel variation and other variables.
I really don't need to pick any fights with any of you guys over this.
Its very simple - the concept is that www.dynoflash.com does ONE tune at a time - done on the dyno - tuned to match the particular car and optimized to the owner's needs. That is what the company does, thats the way we are doing it and just because others do it a different way does not mean they are wrong. There are many approaches to tuning. We feel this is the most professional and careful manner in which to proceed.
Finally, no one can dispute that having a before and after dyno sheet of what the tune is doing - on your car - is a very valuable resource.
I used to order a lot of "chips" and reflashes back in my ole BMW and Mercedes days - - you had to trust the vedor's word as to what HP gains they were claiming. Nothing like seeing it right on your car - verified on a dyno to know what you are getting.
#42
Evolving Member
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Las Vegas
Posts: 329
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hey Al,
no fighting here. I just didn't understand why you would say that after talking so highly about the WORKS reflash. If I lived in the area I would be getting the dynoflash done. Seems like a decent deal to me. I like the idea of having my car personally tuned for the mods I want. As it is I'm nowhere near Pruven so its not an option. Good luck in your new venture.
no fighting here. I just didn't understand why you would say that after talking so highly about the WORKS reflash. If I lived in the area I would be getting the dynoflash done. Seems like a decent deal to me. I like the idea of having my car personally tuned for the mods I want. As it is I'm nowhere near Pruven so its not an option. Good luck in your new venture.
#43
Originally posted by mojo
I don't get it Al just last month you were praising WORKS and how with there through the mail reflash you had achieved so much. Now you state:
"We prefer to stick with a car by car system as Pruven's name and reputation is way too important to risk having problems with slow and dangerous tune through the mail set ups"
Were you happy with the WORKS through the mail flash? If so why would you now be calling it dangerous? Am I missing something? I realize in context you were refering to the Exede but WORKS is through the mail also and you had nothing but good things to say.
I don't get it Al just last month you were praising WORKS and how with there through the mail reflash you had achieved so much. Now you state:
"We prefer to stick with a car by car system as Pruven's name and reputation is way too important to risk having problems with slow and dangerous tune through the mail set ups"
Were you happy with the WORKS through the mail flash? If so why would you now be calling it dangerous? Am I missing something? I realize in context you were refering to the Exede but WORKS is through the mail also and you had nothing but good things to say.
When Alfriedesq gets the eManage, it becomes the best fuel and timing management system - simply amazing he says. Now, it just doesn't cut it. When he gets the works reflash for free probably, he says all the nice stuff....and now this. For all you know, 2 years later when the Skyline GTR comes out... Our cars will become Mitslowbishi Slowvolutions to Alfriedesq. Until now, I don't even understand why tuners or businesses even want to get involved with such a undesirable guy, lowering their corporate image as well. I would rather go with Vishnu Tuning anytime. You guys have no idea how severe the drama was in nasioc when Alfriedesq posted all his c r a p about Evos versus "slowbarus". It made a big part of the Subaru community hate Evos. It took me a lot to buy one, that I had to be associated with ****** like Alfriedesq. But finally I decided that a car is a car, and a ***** is a *****. I won't associate my car in anyway with Alfriedesq, I will not buy any Pruven parts or services.
Last edited by bbyevo8; Sep 17, 2003 at 10:13 PM.
#44
Former Sponsor
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: New York
Posts: 1,112
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Evo11V
I'm going to try pruven's DynoFlash and let everyone know how i like it instead of all this fight talk. I'll give you an honest opinion on the product Pruven is selling.
I'm going to try pruven's DynoFlash and let everyone know how i like it instead of all this fight talk. I'll give you an honest opinion on the product Pruven is selling.
#45
Evolving Member
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Las Vegas
Posts: 329
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hey bbyevo8,
when the GTR gets here I'll be calling my car Mitslowbishi
Al just likes attention and everyone complies and gets all bent up, which off course is the objective. Look at every thread he gets involved in. They all have like 200+ post and everybody is pissed. Its like a fight at recess, everybody wants to watch.
This is his entertainment. You can't take this **** personal, you'll have a heart attack. He just throws anything out there he's thinking without thinking and ends up contradicting himself sometimes.
If I was a vendor I probably wouldn't want him representing me but I'm not a vendor. I'd still try the dynoflash if I was close enough and had a bunch of mods I wanted tuned properly with a reflash. $450 seems reasonable to me for what your getting as long as it's done well.
Take care.
when the GTR gets here I'll be calling my car Mitslowbishi
Al just likes attention and everyone complies and gets all bent up, which off course is the objective. Look at every thread he gets involved in. They all have like 200+ post and everybody is pissed. Its like a fight at recess, everybody wants to watch.
This is his entertainment. You can't take this **** personal, you'll have a heart attack. He just throws anything out there he's thinking without thinking and ends up contradicting himself sometimes.
If I was a vendor I probably wouldn't want him representing me but I'm not a vendor. I'd still try the dynoflash if I was close enough and had a bunch of mods I wanted tuned properly with a reflash. $450 seems reasonable to me for what your getting as long as it's done well.
Take care.