change it yourself or shops
Jan 5, 2010, 08:22 PM
#32
EvoM Community Team Leader
This is probably one of those "If you have to ask" questions.
Jan 5, 2010, 08:25 PM
#33
I've met quite a few mechanics. 95% of them I would not trust to put a clutch in my evo.
It's a hard job. Don't even attempt it unless you consider yourself a competent mechanic in your own right. You're going to need a nice set of tools. That said it is doable. Having done it myself one thing that comes to mind is am I going to trust a guy that works by the hour to take the transmission back out again if he banged up the TOB retaining clip? He has to get done and on to the next job. If it works he'd rather not take that tranny back out. Me personally I want that clip to be perfect. It's going to be depended on at every shift. Nobody is going to take the time and care that you will with your car. Later when you drive off from the shop and 1,000 miles later your TOB pops out do you think the mechanic is going to fess up to it?
That guy early in the thread that said you can have the trans out and back in 2-3 hours made me laugh. Maybe if you've done it 2-3 times before, had at least 1 other guy, and you all drank a pot of coffee before you started the stopwatch.
Jan 5, 2010, 08:34 PM
#34
I can have my dsm tranny out and in in about 3 hrs.
I am getting ready to buy an 06 evo9. It currently has a ATP twin disc on it. I have heard the great things about the twin discs, but I dont know if I can take the sound for too long. If I decide to get rid of it, I am gonna try the clutch job myself.
I have pulled my 1g motor many times as well as other cars. I would think I would be intelligent enough to change the clutch out on an evo?
I am getting ready to buy an 06 evo9. It currently has a ATP twin disc on it. I have heard the great things about the twin discs, but I dont know if I can take the sound for too long. If I decide to get rid of it, I am gonna try the clutch job myself.
I have pulled my 1g motor many times as well as other cars. I would think I would be intelligent enough to change the clutch out on an evo?
keep it coming
Jan 6, 2010, 10:12 PM
#37
Evolving Member
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: seattle
Posts: 154
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Never done it but from what I heard from the guy at the shop who installed my clutch a few years ago, he thought it was the same as the awd eclipse. boy was he wrong, but he got it installed anyways.
Jan 6, 2010, 10:16 PM
#38
evo is a pain in the *** compared to a dsm for clutch job. the 5spds weight like 130lbs and the 6 speed is like 160lbs. The fitment is so tight and you have to go in at just the right angle or you wont clear the rear trans mount/engine roll stop
other than the trans weight and tight fitment, its the same **** with control arms, axles, ball joints, etc.
other than the trans weight and tight fitment, its the same **** with control arms, axles, ball joints, etc.
Jan 6, 2010, 10:41 PM
#39
Evolved Member
i've been a mechanic for 13 years and doing a clutch on your back is NO fun. if you can afford it, do some research and take it to a good shop. not only do they have the tools to do it with, the turnaround time is a day or two. and you will have a warranty. when my 60k came up, i looked for the parts online. the parts and fluids came out to $1000 parts only. and i would still have to spend a day or two for labor. works in cali charged me $1400 and was done in a day. diy is fine, but , if the shop is good, i don't mind putting money back into the auto community. i'm not saying i won't do my clutch on my back, but i would definately let a competent shop do it if the price is reasonable.
Jan 6, 2010, 11:21 PM
#40
i've been a mechanic for 13 years and doing a clutch on your back is NO fun. if you can afford it, do some research and take it to a good shop. not only do they have the tools to do it with, the turnaround time is a day or two. and you will have a warranty. when my 60k came up, i looked for the parts online. the parts and fluids came out to $1000 parts only. and i would still have to spend a day or two for labor. works in cali charged me $1400 and was done in a day. diy is fine, but , if the shop is good, i don't mind putting money back into the auto community. i'm not saying i won't do my clutch on my back, but i would definately let a competent shop do it if the price is reasonable.
clutch jobs for evo's ussually cost around $650 for a evo 8.
Jan 6, 2010, 11:25 PM
#41
+1 ^^^
I've met quite a few mechanics. 95% of them I would not trust to put a clutch in my evo.
It's a hard job. Don't even attempt it unless you consider yourself a competent mechanic in your own right. You're going to need a nice set of tools. That said it is doable. Having done it myself one thing that comes to mind is am I going to trust a guy that works by the hour to take the transmission back out again if he banged up the TOB retaining clip? He has to get done and on to the next job. If it works he'd rather not take that tranny back out. Me personally I want that clip to be perfect. It's going to be depended on at every shift. Nobody is going to take the time and care that you will with your car. Later when you drive off from the shop and 1,000 miles later your TOB pops out do you think the mechanic is going to fess up to it?
That guy early in the thread that said you can have the trans out and back in 2-3 hours made me laugh. Maybe if you've done it 2-3 times before, had at least 1 other guy, and you all drank a pot of coffee before you started the stopwatch.
I've met quite a few mechanics. 95% of them I would not trust to put a clutch in my evo.
It's a hard job. Don't even attempt it unless you consider yourself a competent mechanic in your own right. You're going to need a nice set of tools. That said it is doable. Having done it myself one thing that comes to mind is am I going to trust a guy that works by the hour to take the transmission back out again if he banged up the TOB retaining clip? He has to get done and on to the next job. If it works he'd rather not take that tranny back out. Me personally I want that clip to be perfect. It's going to be depended on at every shift. Nobody is going to take the time and care that you will with your car. Later when you drive off from the shop and 1,000 miles later your TOB pops out do you think the mechanic is going to fess up to it?
That guy early in the thread that said you can have the trans out and back in 2-3 hours made me laugh. Maybe if you've done it 2-3 times before, had at least 1 other guy, and you all drank a pot of coffee before you started the stopwatch.
Jan 7, 2010, 03:21 AM
#42
Evolved Member
iTrader: (14)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: The Stream Of Carol , IL
Posts: 1,095
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
If i have the equpiment and the know how, then i'm doing it myself. I get a great sense of acheievement when I complete a task revolving around my evo. You look at it and you can say "It was a pain in the *** but I did it!"
NOw if you don't have access to a garage and some decent tools then I suggest handing it over to some pros.
NOw if you don't have access to a garage and some decent tools then I suggest handing it over to some pros.
Jan 7, 2010, 09:10 AM
#45
I don't agree with this, you don't need special tools.. infact the only thing you need thats special for the entire job is something to pull the input shaft out that goes through trans to tcase. You just need a full set of 1/2 drives and a nice tq wrench and you can get it done. trans can be pulled out in 2hrs or less... getting it back in is the hard part. 2 sets of tools from craftman and a good snapon tq wrench allowed me to completely redo my entire evo. motor, trans, tcase, blah blah.
Those items just aren't in everyone's garage. That's all. I'm trying to describe it to someone who will be doing it for the first time like me. There's no reason to even attempt to get the tranny out in 2hrs doing it yourself the first time. Take your time. I'm glad it gets so much quicker with each time. I'm sure I could go twice as fast on the next clutch.
Last edited by JohnDoe1984; Jan 7, 2010 at 09:13 AM.