Leaking radiator, whos at fault?
May 14, 2015, 04:18 PM
#1
Evolving Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Morris, IL
Posts: 200
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Leaking radiator, whos at fault?
My radiator started leaking a year after it was installed by a shop. Keep in mind I put about 5000 miles on my car before the radiator failed. It appears the fan's vibrations wore 4-5 holes into the radiator rows. The radiator was a used mishimoto that the shop had on hand. I'm upset because I had no choice but to pay $186.00 for 2 hours of labor to install the radiator and $170 for the radiator itself.
Has anyone ever have a radiator fail due to the electic fan? Is there supposed to be a gasket between the fan and the radiator? Do nylon strips tend to loosen up overtime?
The radiator is currently at mishimoto to see if they will warranty or not. It looks like an installation error so I'm not too hopeful that my radiator will get warrantied.
Has anyone ever have a radiator fail due to the electic fan? Is there supposed to be a gasket between the fan and the radiator? Do nylon strips tend to loosen up overtime?
The radiator is currently at mishimoto to see if they will warranty or not. It looks like an installation error so I'm not too hopeful that my radiator will get warrantied.
May 14, 2015, 04:33 PM
#2
Bro--don't look for fault it just is...Mishimoto makes radiators and with out the fan attached to it the radiator would have been fine--so expect them to laugh--count your blessings if they warrantee it. The fan cause the rub and caused the leak--so whom ever put that on made the mistake--installation error. Its an aftermarket fan as well---so there you have it. Looks to have been installed correctly just someone wasn't paying attention. fan could have a bad bearing causing rocking of the blades and the vibration---but all that's secondary--- a new mishimoto rad is about 240 delivered...a good fan 100-150 by itself. Did you get a good deal upfront yes, bad luck it wasn't a lifetime fix. try again.
May 14, 2015, 04:56 PM
#3
Evolving Member
Thread Starter
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Morris, IL
Posts: 200
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The reason why I'm wondering who is at fault because I didn't install the fan on the radiator. I don't think its a manufacture defect or their fault. I talked to the shop and they offered to send it in to see if it'll get warranted but If it gets declined because of a bad installation, then I'm going to be pissed off if the shop doesn't help with some of the cost for a replacement.
May 14, 2015, 07:32 PM
#5
After a year and 5000 miles, it would be stupid to go after the shop for an installation error. If I were in your shoes, I'd be thanking the shop for taking the time to ship a used part off that they sold over a year ago, most wouldn't do it.
That universal fan looks to be installed correctly (as per the fan manufacture), but is just about the worst way to install a fan. Buy a fan that bolts to the factory fan mounts, or have someone fab up a simple bracket that will attach a universal fan to those same mounts.
That universal fan looks to be installed correctly (as per the fan manufacture), but is just about the worst way to install a fan. Buy a fan that bolts to the factory fan mounts, or have someone fab up a simple bracket that will attach a universal fan to those same mounts.
May 15, 2015, 02:25 PM
#7
That universal fan looks to be installed correctly (as per the fan manufacture), but is just about the worst way to install a fan. Buy a fan that bolts to the factory fan mounts, or have someone fab up a simple bracket that will attach a universal fan to those same mounts.[/QUOTE]
This^^^ I have a mishimoto rad and have had it for 5 or so years, not a prob 1. Also did a slim fan and mounted it to the stock shroud--it ( the shroud) needed to be modified but I never liked the plastic tab mounts-- guessing I was rt. The shop could have easily added some washers to space that fan 1/4' or so off the radiator-- just my .02 but then again, there is just doing it and then doing it rt.
This^^^ I have a mishimoto rad and have had it for 5 or so years, not a prob 1. Also did a slim fan and mounted it to the stock shroud--it ( the shroud) needed to be modified but I never liked the plastic tab mounts-- guessing I was rt. The shop could have easily added some washers to space that fan 1/4' or so off the radiator-- just my .02 but then again, there is just doing it and then doing it rt.
Trending Topics
May 16, 2015, 10:27 AM
#8
Evolving Member
I would be more upset at being charged 2 hours labor for a radiator job. It takes about 30 min to R&R a radiator on an Evo. Also $170 for a used one is on the high side. Shops cost on a new one is around $220 IIRC
May 19, 2015, 08:21 AM
#13
Word. And if they installed without the springs, that could be something to talk to them about. I'm not really a fan of this style of mounting regardless, seems sketchy for a number of reasons, and for temporary use only. Those plastic zip ties can only see so many heat cycles before they get really brittle.
May 20, 2015, 10:37 AM
#14
Evolving Member
20 min would be tough, unless you did not care to make a huge coolant mess. Just pop off the lower one and let it pour out everywhere. And you could skip the bleeding part if you vacuum filled it. But 30 to 45 minutes is very reasonable