View Poll Results: Read Below First ~ Which Winter Tire?
Michelin Pilot Alpin PA2
2
20.00%
Pirelli P Zero Nero M+S
5
50.00%
Toyo Proxes 4
1
10.00%
Turanza LS-Z w/UNI-T AQII
1
10.00%
Yokohama AVS dB S2
1
10.00%
Voters: 10. You may not vote on this poll
Needed Advice for Winter Tires
#1
Newbie
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Orange County, Cali
Posts: 77
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Needed Advice for Winter Tires
I'm trying to purchase a set of tires for my EVO and it's almost like trying to buy x-mas presents for everyone. There's 100's of good products but you just can't find the one that fits.
I have looked though other post but I'm just not impressed with the tiers or reviews.
I drive 45 miles each way to work. 42 miles on the freeway and 3 miles on side streets. We deal with black ice a few times though season and the first 2 years I was here there was maybe 1/4" of snow. Last year though we had around 6" of ice. Pertty much we had a layer ice, snow on top of the ice, freezing rain on the snow, and an ice storm. All in a few hours and the ground was ice for 3+ days.
I could really care about the ice storm because if it happeneds again I will proable stay home but I know I need something that can handle some ice. Oh and it rains here about 96 days starting in Nov. - March.
I need some help. I'm down to these tires and need some advice. Price is not an issue.
I have looked though other post but I'm just not impressed with the tiers or reviews.
I drive 45 miles each way to work. 42 miles on the freeway and 3 miles on side streets. We deal with black ice a few times though season and the first 2 years I was here there was maybe 1/4" of snow. Last year though we had around 6" of ice. Pertty much we had a layer ice, snow on top of the ice, freezing rain on the snow, and an ice storm. All in a few hours and the ground was ice for 3+ days.
I could really care about the ice storm because if it happeneds again I will proable stay home but I know I need something that can handle some ice. Oh and it rains here about 96 days starting in Nov. - March.
I need some help. I'm down to these tires and need some advice. Price is not an issue.
Last edited by MysticMyth; Nov 10, 2004 at 09:23 AM.
#2
Evolved Member
I went with the Dunlop Winter Sport M3. Got them put on today. The razor edge I had with the Advans is gone, but it still grips pretty good in the turn. It's definitely a smoother and quieter ride.
#6
I am being brave and am probably gonna stick with the Advans. I cant afford new wheels and tires and really hate having to mess with mounting and unmounting winter tires. I kept summer tires on my Miata all year round and was just fine...
At least we have AWD...
If you are in or around Salem and want to take a drive sometime PM me...
Later
JT
At least we have AWD...
If you are in or around Salem and want to take a drive sometime PM me...
Later
JT
Last edited by JT_EVO8; Nov 10, 2004 at 03:59 PM.
#7
Former Sponsor
iTrader: (25)
The Pirelli and Yokohama are performance all season based tires. They work well in very light to moderate snow climates. The Pirelli is better than the Yokohama in snow by far. Both aren't bad tires but really wont give you the bite like a dedicated snow tire if you see a lot of snow or ice.
The Turanza LS-Z is a touring all season based tire. The UNI-T compound will make the tire almost adhere to wet surfaces. This makes Bridgestone's some of the best tires for wet traction. The all season traction will be a bit better than the performance all season tires, but your handling will sacrifice to get better ride, life, and snow traction. Might not be the best tire for a performance car like the EVO.
The Pilot Alpin PA-2 will provide the best snow traction and is one of the top for handling in its class. It would handle better than the Turanza's, but not as well as the Pirelli or Yoko. Nothing will be as good in the snow/ice as the Pilot, but you will sacrifice tread wear and some handling to get it.
Personal opinion... I'd go with the Michelin. If there's a possibility of those conditions (accumulated ice and snow for longer periods of time) and you do that much driving, a dedicated snow would be best. I would rather sacrifice some handling and be overly prepared for the worst rather than be stuck 1/2 way home cause I went with an all season tire. I have a very similar commute and used all seasons myself. Once I tried a winter tire I never went back.
The Turanza LS-Z is a touring all season based tire. The UNI-T compound will make the tire almost adhere to wet surfaces. This makes Bridgestone's some of the best tires for wet traction. The all season traction will be a bit better than the performance all season tires, but your handling will sacrifice to get better ride, life, and snow traction. Might not be the best tire for a performance car like the EVO.
The Pilot Alpin PA-2 will provide the best snow traction and is one of the top for handling in its class. It would handle better than the Turanza's, but not as well as the Pirelli or Yoko. Nothing will be as good in the snow/ice as the Pilot, but you will sacrifice tread wear and some handling to get it.
Personal opinion... I'd go with the Michelin. If there's a possibility of those conditions (accumulated ice and snow for longer periods of time) and you do that much driving, a dedicated snow would be best. I would rather sacrifice some handling and be overly prepared for the worst rather than be stuck 1/2 way home cause I went with an all season tire. I have a very similar commute and used all seasons myself. Once I tried a winter tire I never went back.
Trending Topics
#8
Originally Posted by MysticMyth
Ok! Lets try this...Anyone in OR, or WA what will you be running this winter?
#10
Evolved Member
iTrader: (8)
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Salem, OR
Posts: 2,064
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by MysticMyth
Ok! Lets try this...Anyone in OR, or WA what will you be running this winter?
BTW, DO NOT drive with Advans in the snow. I attempted this last year and got down the street before I was sliding out of control off the road.
#11
Evolved Member
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: M-burg , WV
Posts: 626
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So i want a good set of snow tires that will last at least 2 seasons or more. i go through ice rain and snow. sometimes little sometimes alot in wv. Some 1 let me kno what they recommend and my price range is just something half way decent!
#12
Evolved Member
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: oregon coast
Posts: 619
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
hey i am from oregon and have close to the same question. thanks for the tips. i dont have anything but my advans yet, but my commute to work in under 1 mile, and i walk if it isnt pooring down rain.
#14
Evolved Member
iTrader: (1)
Hey there I'm from Oregon.
If I could afford winter tires, I would get Nokian WR. They are true 4-season tires (they even have the snowflake symbol). Jim Bacon tires in Oregon sells them. Dunno where else. I am using my Kumho MX's which seem to do great in rain. I had summer tires on my BMW in germany for 2 years in the snow without trouble, and last year during that huge ice storm I kept the advans on & drove to work every day without trouble. I just avoided steep inclines.
If I could afford winter tires, I would get Nokian WR. They are true 4-season tires (they even have the snowflake symbol). Jim Bacon tires in Oregon sells them. Dunno where else. I am using my Kumho MX's which seem to do great in rain. I had summer tires on my BMW in germany for 2 years in the snow without trouble, and last year during that huge ice storm I kept the advans on & drove to work every day without trouble. I just avoided steep inclines.
#15
I live in colorado, i'm running some 245/40/18 Kuhmo ASX's they have been pretty good so far. Also have heard really good things about the Continental Extremes from all the suby guys