Bilsteins vs. oem
#33
Evolved Member
iTrader: (18)
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Philadelphia, PA
Posts: 1,337
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
True, if you want some questionably made and harsh riding coilovers. Any coilover with a smidgen of ride comfort will set you back atleast 2k+. This is for entry kw's, hr coilovers, bilstein pss9. Or you can buy my used kw's for 1700 with springs rates that actually work!
#34
Evolved Member
I want to upgrade my GSR to Bilsteins. My plan is to use them in conjunction with a slight drop that something like the Swifts would give me. However, now there is a bit of confusion because apparently some 2005+ GSR received Bilsteins as OEM equipment as opposed to KYB's? Lancershop shows two types of Bilsteins.
I'm guessing I want the yellow "HD" models and I would then have to buy MR type lowering springs, but I was just wondering if someone could offer a bit of clarification - as I am guessing the more expensive (on their site) but non-HD "silver" Bilsteins are comparable to the standard KYBs and don't offer a performance upgrade - even though they say some MRs got them:
Here are the ones I think I need: http://www.lancershop.com/customer/p...cat=104&page=1
Here are the ones that are throwing me off: http://www.lancershop.com/customer/p...cat=104&page=1
I'm guessing I want the yellow "HD" models and I would then have to buy MR type lowering springs, but I was just wondering if someone could offer a bit of clarification - as I am guessing the more expensive (on their site) but non-HD "silver" Bilsteins are comparable to the standard KYBs and don't offer a performance upgrade - even though they say some MRs got them:
Here are the ones I think I need: http://www.lancershop.com/customer/p...cat=104&page=1
Here are the ones that are throwing me off: http://www.lancershop.com/customer/p...cat=104&page=1
#35
Evolved Member
iTrader: (8)
Only Evo that came stock with Bilsteins was the MR version, GSR had KYBs.
HDs are the replacement struts from Bilstein. Their valving is slightly firmer than the OEM MRs.
Thats just a stock file from Lancershop. Bilsteins are yellow.
I ran Bilstein HD (all four) with GSR Swift Sports and SpecRs.
HDs are the replacement struts from Bilstein. Their valving is slightly firmer than the OEM MRs.
Thats just a stock file from Lancershop. Bilsteins are yellow.
I ran Bilstein HD (all four) with GSR Swift Sports and SpecRs.
#36
Evolved Member
HDs are the replacement struts from Bilstein. Their valving is slightly firmer than the OEM MRs.
#37
Evolved Member
iTrader: (8)
Yes. The HDs are softer than the KYBs. Just a little bit firmer than the MRs.
For Swifts, the MR drop the rear less by .14in.
Swift Spec Rs: F: 157 (helper section) 358 (main rate), R: 196 (helper section) 380 (main rate). -1.4, -0.8 drop.
Swift Spec Rs MR: F: 157 (helper section) 358 (main rate), R: 153 (helper section) 380 (main rate). -1.4, -0.66 drop.
For Swifts, the MR drop the rear less by .14in.
Swift Spec Rs: F: 157 (helper section) 358 (main rate), R: 196 (helper section) 380 (main rate). -1.4, -0.8 drop.
Swift Spec Rs MR: F: 157 (helper section) 358 (main rate), R: 153 (helper section) 380 (main rate). -1.4, -0.66 drop.
#38
Evolved Member
iTrader: (21)
On the other hand, if I had to choose fixed struts I would go with the HD's and springs.
FWIW I got stock KYB (blew one) then got MR bilsteins ( did not like them AT ALL, way too soft) and finally went for the PSS9 ( only because I got tired of waiting for the HD's to become available).
#39
Evolved Member
Uh, oh - is that not backwards from what I read here?:
I actually have an email from them before I bought these springs...
As for the differences between the MR(4M017R) and the GSR(4M008R) springs. There is a slight difference between the GSR and the MR spring but it will be noticeable if they are installed. If you were to put an MR spring onto your GSR then the rear end will drop even lower by about 15-20 mill. And vice versa if you were to swap the GSR onto the MR.
As for the differences between the MR(4M017R) and the GSR(4M008R) springs. There is a slight difference between the GSR and the MR spring but it will be noticeable if they are installed. If you were to put an MR spring onto your GSR then the rear end will drop even lower by about 15-20 mill. And vice versa if you were to swap the GSR onto the MR.
#40
Evolved Member
iTrader: (8)
Gas pressures are different in the MR Bilsteins. Rear MR springs are 3-4mm higher than the GSR versions. Reason is for the increase pressure the Bilsteins have - as tested by Swift.
PS - doing a driving meet/greet/food run in AL on 2/5:
https://www.evolutionm.net/forums/so...-2-5-10am.html
PS - doing a driving meet/greet/food run in AL on 2/5:
https://www.evolutionm.net/forums/so...-2-5-10am.html
Last edited by Smike; Jan 18, 2011 at 09:30 AM.
#41
Newbie
iTrader: (6)
I hope it's okay to bump this useful thread. I just got my IX RS and I've found the ride to be remarkably rigid for a production car. It reminds me of my old Neon ACR with the struts set at full stiff. This makes for a crisp ride on the street which I certainly don't mind but might not prove the best in the dirt. From what I gather here as well as some other threads, the MR Bilstein setup is slightly more compliant.
#42
Evolved Member
iTrader: (33)
I hope it's okay to bump this useful thread. I just got my IX RS and I've found the ride to be remarkably rigid for a production car. It reminds me of my old Neon ACR with the struts set at full stiff. This makes for a crisp ride on the street which I certainly don't mind but might not prove the best in the dirt. From what I gather here as well as some other threads, the MR Bilstein setup is slightly more compliant.
My particular setup was HD Bilstiens and Swift SpecR's. IF I hadn't conveted my car into a dedicated track machine, I would still have that setup on it for DD.
#43
Evolving Member
iTrader: (4)
Is lancershop.com the only place to order the bilstien HD`s? I saw them at tirerack.com, but it looked like the fronts were HD and the rears were not... anyone got any clarification on this as I am planning on doing this set up very soon and last time I was on lancershop.com I could not find them on there.
#44
Evolved Member
iTrader: (23)
Is lancershop.com the only place to order the bilstien HD`s? I saw them at tirerack.com, but it looked like the fronts were HD and the rears were not... anyone got any clarification on this as I am planning on doing this set up very soon and last time I was on lancershop.com I could not find them on there.
If you look up the part number for the "Sport", which are the fronts, it will come up as "Bilstein B6 Heavy Duty".
This website has both with the part numbers.
http://www.eshocks.com/bil_Ind.asp?VC=92Q24&SubChar=Q
This website also has both front and rear listed as "HD" with matching part number from the link above.
http://www.allshocks.com/bilstein/ht...year='2005'
And lastly, I managed to find a thread about this.
https://www.evolutionm.net/forums/ev...in-shocks.html
I was just looking at TireRack and here is what i found.
Bilstein HD Shock
Manufacturer Part #: F4-BE5-B844-H0
rear fitment
Bilstein Sport Strut
Manufacturer Part #: F4-VE3-B843-H2
Front Fitment
those are the only availability. So pretty much you are getting a pair of sport and a pair of HD altogether if you want 4 of them?
Oh and estimated availability is less than 3. <------ meaning there might not be any in stock?
Bilstein HD Shock
Manufacturer Part #: F4-BE5-B844-H0
rear fitment
Bilstein Sport Strut
Manufacturer Part #: F4-VE3-B843-H2
Front Fitment
those are the only availability. So pretty much you are getting a pair of sport and a pair of HD altogether if you want 4 of them?
Oh and estimated availability is less than 3. <------ meaning there might not be any in stock?
And there you have it. What's listed as "Sport" is actually "HD". There is no "Sport" for the Evo.